Andy was never one to back down. She had a job, and for the first time, she had failed. Alone she drove up to Chicago, after Riley. Riley was there on a short visit to Jack. Their unstable relationship was apparent, and all the while, Andy watched from the darkness. With her many sources, she kept track of the trio, following them all around the city. They were aware of her too. Meanwhile, Alyssa had figured out that Drake was a traitor, and was out on a mission after him. Andy joined in on the "Drake" hunt, still watching Riley, Jack and Luke every second. Andy figured Drake would be desperate to get in touch with the trio, so she followed him, knowing they would have to meet up. Of course, out of guilt and thanks, Riley met Drake at a local bus stop. The now four of them split up, and Riley and Luke were all alone. Alyssa made her move on Drake and Jack. All the noise from the scene caused Riley and Luke to run back over to their friends. As Drake and Alyssa fought, and Luke and Riley discussed Jack's morals, Alyssa was hit square in the stomach by Riley's gunshot. She fell back in to Drake arms and the two of them left the scene. They were still friends, something that Andy found extremely hard to comprehend. Andy watched the scene in disgust. Making her appearance, another battle took place. In the end, Andy realized that power and strength wouldn't be enough to beat Riley. They had something she didn't, and whatever it was, it ended up leaving Andy on the ground with an electric mark in her side. As Jack, Luke and Riley headed off to Providence, Andy was determined to figure out how to defeat them. . .whatever it took.

Providence was a quiet town. Andy had chased after Riley, Jack and Luke, watching them every second every day. For the first time in a long time, Andy made no noise in this Rhode Island city. She stayed quiet, haunting the shadows, and studied Luke's tenseness, Riley's new found bravery, and JR's changing heart. The three of them stuck together, meeting up with a young boy by the name of Mitchell. As Riley's troupe got bigger, Andy did one thing she had never done before. She gave up. She traveled away for the eastern sea shore, and drove. She knew she would meet up with them again some day, but right now, she needed a break from everything.

It seems old friends and enemies have a way of catching up with you. Andy had retreated. She ran . . . all the way to Las Vegas, Nevada to recollect herself. She resorted to a life of gambling and drinking, thinking maybe, this life wouldn't be so bad. And then. . .it happened. Riley and Jack drove past. Fate, huh? Andy lept after them, following them all the way to their hotel. Finally, giving them a ring to let them know she was in town, her "payback" was about to begin. After Riley and Jack had figured out she was there, they went down to the casino. Andy, using many of her specialties, decided to give Riley a little gift. She snuck a little poison into the girl's drink, and then snuck out. Riley was rushed to the hospital, but the fun didn't stop there. Andy had the power cut off, making Jack, Riley and now Scott Lewis go all the way down to the basement to save the countless people dying, in the dark hospital. Of course, Andy was there waiting. After a quick battle scene, both Jack and Andy walked away injured. Andy, once again disgusted at her failure, wandered to a bar, where she pasted out. While unconscious, she had a dream, or "deja-vu" as you might call it, about her and her younger brother, Durrick. Sure enough, as she lay there, Riley and Jack were on their way to kidnap the boy, figuring that was their only way to defeat her. When they came back, they gave Andy a ring, telling her to come to their hotel to claim her brother. Andy freaked. She didn't know what to do, considering the fact she hadn't seen the kid in 15 years. Quickly going to the hotel, she found two more visitors, Isabella and Mitch from the future, waiting for her as well. As they all demanded for her to drop the gun and surrender, Andy stood there, still. She had a choice to make, between her brother, or her pride. The one person who had ever loved her, or the one thing she could get by on. In the end, she left, like they said. She had given up and boarded a bus, hoping, that they would spare her brother's life.